OVERALL: Draw

The US Flicker Alley and the UK releases for including all surviving 34 films, newly restored with extras, though note the Flicker Alley set have the films in PAL to NTSC transfers.
Note that the runtimes of the 1997 restored films are significantly different from the Chaplin Keystone Project restorations due to differing projection speeds and sourced from differing prints.

Of the 35 Keystone film starring Chaplin, only "Her Friend the Bandit" is still lost.

Information between various the restored / public domain collections on the films can be found at Brenton Film's "Charlie Chaplin Collectors’ Guide, Part 2"

CUTS:

• R0 America- Flicker Alley - No cuts - restored versions of the 34 surviving Chaplin Keystone films, part of the Chaplin Keystone Project (2003-2010) (PAL to NTSC transfers).
• R0 Tillie's Punctured Romance America- Image Entertainment - No cuts - Includes two of the Keystone films, 1997 restoration.
• R2 United Kingdom- British Film Institute - No cuts - restored versions of the 34 surviving Chaplin Keystone films, part of the Chaplin Keystone Project (2003-2010).

Do you own a release not listed? Then please visit our forums and let us know!

Comparison added by James-Masaki_Ryan on 15/03/16
Comparison last updated by James-Masaki_Ryan on 23/06/17

UPDATE LOG:

15/03/16: Initial entry.
23/06/17: Added US Image.